The Worst of the ‘Best of Atlanta’
Saturday, January 20th, 2007Drumroll please…. and the winner of the Worst ‘Best of Atlanta’ issue is? Gwinnett Magazine! … Please Wrap Up.
Seriously. Best of issues are great. They let editors and experts on a town give you insight in the the restaurants, schools, architecture, and local folks who deserve praise. However, lots of best of issues have turned gutless. They have multiple winners or they make sure that the popular vote an the critical vote recognize two different winners.
Gwinnett Magazine however, takes the cake. In their category for ‘Best Place for a Business Meeting or Retreat’, they list Evergreen Conference Center (in Stone Mountain Park) and Chateau Elan… Neither of which are actually IN Gwinnett! Not only did they fail in deciding on a winner, but they chose facilities that should be ineligible for their decision! At the top of the issue they ask “Have you really looked at Gwinnett lately?” Apparently not as they can’t even find the county boarders!
Right now, the best ‘Best of Atlanta‘ issue is the one published by ‘Creative Loafing’. The categories are pretty consistent and hit the essentials. They divide readers and critics, who do seem to make an effort to distinguish between ‘most popular’ and actual ‘best’.
Other publications try but are not as good. However, there is one category that seems to scare Atlantans. No one ranks schools in this town. No one puts all the elementary, secondary, and high schools together and declares one of each the best. Heck, they won’t even do it by department! What gives? If you’re willing to declare a given person the best politician, or a given restaurant the best food, why not give people something really useful? Best math department! If Businessweek can rank the top business schools in the world, surely the AJC can rank the best schools.
(Note: A year ago, Atlanta Magazine name this Bloglanta best Blog. We appreciate that very much.)