Jim Wooten, AJC Columnist recently wrote:
“MARTA is in serious financial difficulty. Its reserves, at the current rate of spending, will evaporate in another 2-3 years.
“Its board can play games. Its unions and interest groups can delude themselves into believing that the state will ride to the rescue, if only enough pressure is mounted and if the phrase is repeated often enough that no other major transit system operates without a state subsidy. The state’s response though, as expressed in a 2003 letter to MARTA, is to get its house in order and operate as a business.
“MARTA’s first obligation, plain and simple, is to balance the budget responsibly and on its own. Its existing funds are sufficient. There is no Sugar Daddy. There is no tooth fairy. There is no masked man riding to the rescue — nor should there be.
For most all of its operating life, MARTA has been a business operating as a social welfare agency, making decisions — including where to build lines — for political rather than marketplace reasons. The day of reckoning we knew would come is here.”
While I think Mr. Wooten is twisting the facts and is dead wrong, his sentiments are currently popular and people who support transit had better gear up with some truth to fight those who think as he does so…
Does MARTA have a perception problem and perhaps an economization problem? Yes. Must MARTA lower executive bonuses and top level salaries and put the focus on keeping bus lines running and electricity flowing? Yes.
Can MARTA operate as a business? Absolutely not. First, MARTA is an externality based enterprise. Its goal is not to profit from its undertakings but to serve the people, including the poorest among us, by getting them where they need to be and in so doing relieving highway traffic for the rest of the state.
If MARTA were to operate as a business, it would hike fares to $2.50, cut most bus service, put additional charges on routes from the airports and lower its capital spending dramatically.
However, the State controls how MARTA spends it’s money. It can’t, as would any other business, decide how to allocate its recsources. Also, if MARTA cuts all that bus service and smacks on serious additional charges to ride from the airport, that will affect convention traffic, and when convention traffic goes, Sales Taxes go down. It hurts everyone.
Should MARTA get state funds? Absolutely. However, MARTA would settle for being able to use the funds it has in the way they are needed… just like any other business.