“City” means city
Monday, January 29th, 2007Some of my blogging friends have been doing quotes of the day lately. I spotted this jewel in today’s AJC:
Milton, a community of horse farms, golf courses and mansions, decided to become its own city last year in order to limit growth and its effects.
Dear Milton,
If you wanted to limit growth, why would you become a city? You’ve just created a new layer of bureaucracy that you have to support on your own. And the city council is going to deal with budgeting issues every year. To solve those issues, they need tax revenue. To get tax revenue, they will from now to forever have to worry about the community’s economic development.
Your real misfortune was not that you are located in the northern sticks of Fulton County. Oh no. Your misfortune comes from the 1983 Georgia Constitution. From the New Georgia Encyclopedia:
Counties are allowed to provide:
—police and fire protection
—garbage and solid waste collection and disposal
—public health facilities and services, including hospitals, ambulances, emergency rescue, and animal control
—street and road construction, including curbs, sidewalks, and street lights
—parks, recreational areas, facilities, and programs
—storm-water and sewage collection and disposal systems
—water utilities
—public housing
—public transportation
—libraries, archives, and arts/sciences programs and facilities
—terminal and dock facilities and parking facilities
—codes, including building, housing, plumbing, and electrical codes
—air quality control
—planning and zoning
These supplementary powers address citizens’ demands to improve and maintain the state’s quality of life. Cities and towns have long offered these services, but they were seldom seen outside the urban environment.
What does it all mean? It means every county can effectively be a city. It means every city will forever be dysfunctional because their ability to grow, and their ability to provide effective and efficient services will be hampered because county governments are already providing municipal services.The change in the Georgia Constitution was made because — like the god damn babies they always have been and always will be — Georgia’s rural and suburban citizens wanted to have their cake and eat it, too. “Waa! I want my bucolic setting, and I want my municipal services, too! And keep my taxes low, while you’re at it!”
Now, Milton, you are among those suffering the consequences. Tough luck.
Fellow metro Atlanta citizens, you reap what you sow. You associated the City of Atlanta with crime, corruption, and a generally unbucolic setting. Rather than doing something about it, you decided it better to vote with your feet and run away from the problems. That’s not how problems go away. It should be no suprise that they follow you when you vote with your feet.
The few among you who voted in 1983 had the chance to keep counties as counties and cities as cities. You were sold a tax-hungry sham. You could have kept Atlanta within its city limits. And you could have had a chance to have some power of your own in seeing Atlanta’s problems fixed — complete with a more powerful way to vote: by kicking out dirty politicians.
Let the City of Atlanta expand its borders, and its balance of power will shift faster than you can say “gentrification.” Stop forming new cities and counties — you will solve nothing. You will cause more problems for yourselves. You will try to not grow, which will force your fellow crybabies to move further out and settle more of the countryside. And they will clog your roads. And you will have no money to widen your roads that you worked so hard to avoid having to widen.
Today, you take your municipal services for granted, and you pretend that you pay more in taxes than you get back. Your utilities and infrastructure, which were built to allow you to live out in the middle of boringland, are expensive. No matter to what extent federal and state governments subsidize your infrastructure, you ultimately pay for these things with your taxes. People of Pretend-Milton County: You reap what you sow.
Congratulations on creating your own problems.